When the chilly climate rolls in, nothing hits the spot fairly like a warming bowl of hen noodle soup. The salty broth, tender hen, and comfortable noodles can work wonders on a chilly winter night time. You do not want us to inform you how therapeutic this soup can really feel you probably have a chilly or the flu, too.

However not all hen noodle soups are created equal—and that is the place we are available in. We shopped for 10 totally different hen noodle soups that will help you determine which cold-weather treatment you need to search for the subsequent time you desire a tasty bowl of sizzling soup.

And for extra, do not miss these 15 Traditional American Desserts That Deserve a Comeback.

To find out which hen noodle soup gave us the warmest emotions, we heated every one within the microwave and tasted them individually. No crackers or accompanying sides had been current—we judged them as they got here within the packaging, with out doctoring them up with any spices or add-ins. We based mostly our ranking on three issues: noodles, saltiness, and total taste.

In alphabetical order, the hen noodle soups we tried had been:

• Annie’s Natural Hen Noodle Soup
• Campbell’s Hen Noodle Soup
• Campbell’s Properly Sure! Hen Noodle Soup
• Full Circle Market Natural Hen Noodle Soup
• Wholesome Valley Hen Noodle Soup
• Lipton Hen Noodle Soup
• Pacific Hen Noodle Soup with Hen Bone Broth
• Progresso Diminished Sodium Roasted Hen Noodle Soup
• Dealer Joe’s Hen Soup
• Wolfgang Puck Natural Free Vary Hen Noodle Soup

Now, ranked from worst to finest, see how these 10 stacked up—and which one we named as the very best. (Trace: We had been shocked by the best choice.)

RELATED: Join our e-newsletter to get each day recipes and meals information in your inbox!

Wholesome Valley’s title ought to’ve been the lifeless giveaway. “Wholesome” is not precisely what individuals need once they’re on the lookout for a flavorful hen noodle soup—you desire a soup that tastes salty and hearty. We had been removed from followers of this canned soup, which led to it putting lifeless final on our listing.

Eat This, Not That! Verdict

Our taste-test group was not into this hen noodle soup in any respect. In accordance with one taste-tester, it was “completely disgusting. Tasted like heat dishwater.” Two separate individuals acknowledged that this one had an “odd” and “completely horrible” aftertaste. And whenever you’re consuming hen noodle soup, you don’t need a lingering style in your mouth, aside from one in all juicy, scrumptious hen.

Initially, we had been enthusiastic about this soup as a result of its noodle form was so distinctive compared to the others, and the colourful colours of the carrots had been interesting. However, sadly, the style of this soup landed it close to the underside of our listing. We would’ve beloved the noodles, however that was it. Generally, issues look higher than they style, and that was the case right here.

Eat This, Not That! Verdict

“The noodles? Unbelievable. However the broth tasted just like the cardboard field it got here out of,” one editor acknowledged. One other particular person thought it “tasted extra like carrot noodle soup than hen noodle. Very blah.”

One editor “appreciated the noodles, however sadly, the style and taste had been severely missing.” “The place was the hen?” one other taster requested. Apparently, she bought spoonfuls of simply carrots and noodles.

“The noodles had been enjoyable, however that is the one redeeming high quality. The style was nonexistent,” one other taster mentioned.

This was the one hen noodle soup of its type in our take a look at. For this soup, you’re taking the dry package deal out of the field and add water to the elements in a bowl. The soup got here out of the microwave effective, however after sitting for a minute, it turned tremendous thick. It might probably have been higher if we made it on the stovetop, however the consistency wasn’t the one drawback our tasters had with this soup. The overwhelming salty taste was what landed this combine in our backside three.

Eat This, Not That! Verdict

One in all our editors remembered this combine from her childhood and was excited to attempt it once more—however she shortly realized this did not style just like the model her mother used to make. “The sodium on this was next-level. Method an excessive amount of. Nevertheless, this was a childhood favourite, so I respect the nostalgia that comes with the flavour,” she mentioned.

One other taster complained concerning the “overpowering saltiness” of this Lipton soup. And one other questioned the plain yellow coloration of the broth, including that the hen items had been “powerful and onerous to chew.” This was higher than the final two soups, however not adequate to get larger rankings throughout.

This boxed soup wasn’t so unhealthy, however it wasn’t adequate to make the highest half of the listing. The number of greens within the combine appeared nice, however the total style stored this soup from being one of the vital loved of the batch.

Eat This, Not That! Verdict

One tester mentioned, “This was harking back to hen noodle soup, however with none precise taste.” One other taster mentioned one thing comparable: “I appreciated the pasta, however the broth was fairly bland.”

In accordance with our group, the look of this soup was “very pure.” However one taster thought the soup from this field had a “steel aftertaste.” She wrote that the soup left a foul style in her mouth after she tried the pattern, and one other taster agreed. “Regardless of the field was made from was coming off into the soup. I did not like this in any respect,” she mentioned.

Nonetheless, this soup did get some constructive critiques from a few of our tasters. One particular person wrote that she “beloved the form of the noodles, and the carrots supplied a pleasant hearty taste.” One other loved the soup, writing that she “beloved the bone broth in right here, and it tasted low in sodium. The feel of this noodle was additionally pretty.”

No, this is not only a rebranded look of your go-to can of Campbell’s. That is the Properly Sure! model of Campbell’s Hen Noodle Soup, which is made with lean hen meat, quinoa-based egg noodles, carrots, and beans. It landed simply shy of a top-five spot on our listing.

Eat This, Not That! Verdict

We docked factors on this one for coloration. It was an “orange coloration. It was very odd, and the hen chunks appeared quite scary, however the style was nice and I beloved the beans and celery blended in,” one taster famous.

“The broth and noodles weren’t unhealthy, however it was a bit bland,” one particular person wrote. One other editor appreciated the packaging and mentioned that it was “loads higher than common Campbell’s, however nonetheless bland.”

If you consider hen noodle soup, we’re positive you consider this pink and white can first. Nevertheless, in our style take a look at, this iconic can solely positioned fifth. It might sound powerful to beat, however we discovered 4 stunning picks that actually stood above this traditional.

Eat This, Not That! Verdict

This one will all the time be a traditional. One editor mentioned it was “just a little too salty now that we tasted it subsequent to the others.” And one other mentioned that “the salt was insufferable on this soup. Additionally, the dearth of veggies was disappointing.”

A 3rd particular person additionally mentioned this soup was “so salty. Didn’t just like the hen on this one.” Nevertheless, it acquired excessive rankings for nostalgia. It reminded a few of their childhood, however others thought that the “solely good a part of this soup was the can.”

Nonetheless, the unique Campbell’s soup had that traditional style, which led one editor to reminisce about her “childhood reminiscences ingesting this after a snow day.” She added that Campbell’s was a “go-to” when she was sick, saying you “cannot beat it” for the nostalgia issue alone.

RELATED: The straightforward method to make more healthy consolation meals.

This refrigerated soup did not have noodles, however the truth that it was lacking a key ingredient and nonetheless landed in our fourth spot exhibits how a lot our tasters beloved its heartier taste.

Eat This, Not That! Verdict

Our editors began their critiques off by raving concerning the total texture. “The hen was good. Beloved the broth regardless that it appeared a bit oily from the fats,” one particular person commented. “The flavour jumped out… it tasted probably the most pure and home made,” one other editor mentioned. And a 3rd particular person mentioned the soup was like “consuming freshly shredded hen. The broth was flavorful with fats, and the veggies additionally tasted contemporary.”

This natural model was a darkish horse within the race. Usually identified for its snacks and mac and cheese, Annie’s stunned our group with a very nice and uniquely-flavored hen noodle soup, touchdown it a spot in our high three.

Eat This, Not That! Verdict

Editors raved concerning the “good, hefty chunks of hen and contemporary style.” One taster “beloved the savory style on this soup.” She added that “the mix of spices was very nice,” and mentioned she “would eat an entire bowl of this and really feel comfortably full.” And one editor thought this soup had the noodles with “the very best form.”

Our solely grievance? One particular person thought this soup “wanted salt, however total had a superb wholesome and clear aftertaste.” This healthy-tasting soup happy lots of our group members.

This lower-sodium model of Progresso’s roasted hen noodle soup acquired nice scores throughout. This soup is really the perfect of each worlds: It was each scrumptious and more healthy than most hen noodle soup choices.

Eat This, Not That! Verdict

The hearty add-ins on this soup helped it climb to the second spot in our style take a look at. Our testers thought this one was “excellent and tasted like a wholesome model of regular soup we had from our childhood.” One other editor was a “large fan of this one and appreciated the chunky carrots and the noodle form. Additionally, it had herbs in it, which we appreciated.” One final editor beloved this, saying “Wonderful! Nice taste and massive carrots. So fresh-tasting!”

With an virtually unanimous choice as primary, Wolfgang Puck’s hen noodle soup took the highest spot in our style take a look at. We beloved this soup and wouldn’t cease speaking about it. We will certainly be heading again to our native grocery retailer to search out this soup after we are beginning to really feel below the climate or want a warming winter meal.

Eat This, Not That! Verdict

One editor could not include their pleasure, stating, “Lastly! one! Carrots had been flavorful, and it didn’t style prefer it got here from a can.” One other thought “the form of the carrots had been pretty, it appeared like they had been truly chopped as a substitute of fake-like cubes in different soups. This one had a very nice taste total.”

Different editors thought this one was “scrumptious” and had “nice large items of hen and an ideal broth.” One editor mentioned, “I might eat this on a regular basis.”

“Wolfgang Puck would not disappoint. I might get this at a pleasant restaurant as an appetizer,” mentioned one taster. “The carrots had been good and comfortable.” And one final editor acknowledged, “Now this was an actual hen noodle soup. The hen taste wasn’t overpowering, however completely current. Nice ratio of noodles and hen to broth.”

When you’re on the lookout for an ideal hen noodle soup that is stuffed with taste, we suggest this Wolfgang Puck model for a soup that tastes home made. And for extra canned must-haves, do not miss these 10 Canned Meals You Ought to All the time Hold In Your Pantry.