5 Major Differences Between Costco and BJ’s Right Now — Eat This Not That

By Ghuman

Introduction

If you’re looking for a new place to shop for groceries, you may be considering Costco and BJ’s. Both stores offer a wide selection of products at competitive prices, but there are some key differences between the two. Here are five major differences between Costco and BJ’s right now that you should consider before making your decision. First, Costco offers a larger selection of products than BJ’s. Second, Costco has a more generous return policy than BJ’s. Third, Costco offers a wider variety of services than BJ’s, such as a pharmacy, optical center, and gas station. Fourth, Costco has a more generous rewards program than BJ’s. Finally, Costco has a larger selection of organic and natural products than BJ’s.

5 Major Differences Between Costco and BJ’s Right Now

Costco and BJ’s are two of the most popular wholesale clubs in the United States. Both offer great deals on bulk items, but there are some key differences between the two. Here are five major differences between Costco and BJ’s right now.

1. Membership Fees

Costco’s membership fees are slightly higher than BJ’s. Costco’s basic membership is $60 per year, while BJ’s basic membership is $55 per year. However, BJ’s offers a variety of additional membership levels that can offer additional savings.

2. Store Locations

Costco has more than 700 stores in the United States, while BJ’s has just over 200. This means that Costco is more widely available than BJ’s, and it may be easier to find a Costco store near you.

3. Product Selection

Costco offers a wider selection of products than BJ’s. Costco has a larger selection of groceries, electronics, and other items, while BJ’s focuses more on home goods and apparel. BJ’s also offers a wider selection of organic and natural products.

4. Online Shopping

Costco offers online shopping with delivery and pickup options, while BJ’s does not. This means that if you want to shop online, you’ll have to go with Costco.

5. Return Policy

Costco has a generous return policy, allowing customers to return most items within 90 days of purchase. BJ’s return policy is more restrictive, allowing customers to return most items within 30 days of purchase.

Both Costco and BJ’s Wholesale Club is well-known for exclusive memberships, big-bulk items, and specialty store brands. Costco was founded in 1976, while BJ’s emerged years later in 1984, but both have since been compared to one another over time. While the stores have overlapping characteristics, there are still several key differences in how they operate.

In the tossup between the shopping clubs, we’ve discovered some notable differences that make each brand stand apart. Check out the five biggest differences between Costco and BJ’s.

RELATED: 6 Things You’ll See at Costco This Year

coupons
Shutterstock

Unlike Costco, BJ’s accepts manufacturers’ coupons—and is the only club to do so—meaning that shoppers can save on individual name brands like Cheerios, Wheat Thins, or Nature Valley bars. BJ’s company website even encourages members to “stack them on top of in-Club coupons.”

Costco, however, does not accept general manufacturer coupons and its website explains why it decided to go in a different direction—it already has sales and offers sourced straight from the warehouse itself. The company says that it’s also a matter of keeping the prices low, because “Manufacturers, meanwhile, often will simply ‘load’ the cost of a coupon program into the original pricing of their product.” It adds that “Because it ultimately doesn’t provide any advantage to the member, we don’t permit our vendors or buyers to carry out that practice at Costco.”

Costco food court
Shutterstock

As another major arm of the warehouse brand, Costco’s beloved food court attracts members with its famous $1.50 hot dogs, along with fan favorites like the pizza and the onion crank. But BJ’s members don’t have the luxury of a food court. There was one once upon a time, but the food courts have been replaced with Dunkin’ Donuts kiosks since 2016.

membership
Shutterstock

BJ’s basic membership status costs $55 annually, and its premium membership is $110 per year. If you want to bypass the membership dues, BJ’s offers a 1-Day Shopping Pass for online shopping on the store’s website … keep in mind, though, that there’s a 20% surcharge for non-members. It also doesn’t carry all the perks of a regular membership. Shoppers can only use the “Ship It” service; BJ’s notes that its free “In-Club Pickup” and “Same-Day Delivery” options aren’t part of the deal.

As for Costco, yearly dues are $60 for the Gold Star/Business basic membership, and for double that amount, you can get the Gold Star Executive/Business Executive membership. Like BJ’s, Costco offers non-member shopping for the company’s online store, with non-members expected to pay a surcharge. However, unlike BJ’s 20% surcharge, Costco has a non-member surcharge of only 5%. Shoppers can’t purchase any of the “member only” items, but the warehouse pharmacy, optical center, and vaccination sites are all available and open to the public!

wholesale products
Shutterstuck

BJ’s revealed in a 2017 call with investors that at the time a typical store offers about 7,000 products. There isn’t much word on if the number of items has changed since then, but the company says the number of items is “roughly double the assortment found in Costco or Sam’s Club but well below what is found in a typical supermarket and dramatically less than what Walmart or Target offer.”

Costco has significantly fewer items and it is considered to “…carry about 4,000 SKUs (stock keeping units) compared to the 30,000 found at most supermarkets,” according to the website.

costco workers
Shutterstuck

In total, Costco has established close to 600 stores in 482 cities across the United States, with California making up a whopping 22% of these Costco stores (with 132 locations operating in the state alone).

BJ’s has significantly fewer store locations in comparison, with only 215 stores in 16 states according to the company’s website. This means a stark difference as far as the number of employees with BJ’s 25,000 team members versus Costco’s 189,000 employees.

In fact, Costco’s Rival Is Opening Up New Locations Across the Country.